Skip to main content

Arrest ≠ Guilt: Rethinking India’s Proposed Law on Removing Elected Leaders

The new bills propose automatic removal of a PM, CM, or Minister if:

  • Arrested and detained for 30 consecutive days
  • The alleged offence carries a 5+ year sentence
  • No conviction is required—removal is triggered by custody alone

This raises a fundamental question: Are we rewriting the rules of democracy to suit the mood of the moment?

🧭 What Do Other Democracies Do?

Let’s take a quick tour:

Country

Removal Trigger

Requires Conviction?

Process

🇺🇸 USA

Impeachment

No (but serious charges)

House vote + Senate trial

🇬🇧 UK

No-confidence vote

No

Parliamentary vote

🇩🇪 Germany

Constructive no-confidence

No

Must elect successor simultaneously

🇫🇷 France

Parliamentary process

No

Complex constitutional procedure

🇯🇵 Japan

No-confidence vote

No

Legislative decision

Across these democracies, arrest alone does not equal removal. The principle of “innocent until proven guilty” is not just legal—it’s foundational.

⚖️ India’s Proposal: A Democratic Shortcut?

The proposed bill bypasses:

  • Due process
  • Judicial verdicts
  • Legislative checks

Instead, it places immense power in the hands of investigative agencies. In a politically charged environment, this could be weaponized to destabilize opposition governments or silence dissent.

Imagine a scenario where a popular CM is arrested under a controversial law, held for 31 days, and removed—only to be acquitted later. The damage is done. The mandate is overturned. The people’s voice is muted.

🔎 Who Is Currently Affected?

As of now, no sitting Prime Minister or Chief Minister has crossed the 30-day custody threshold under this new law. However, several leaders have been recently arrested or investigated, and could be impacted if the bills pass:

🧑‍⚖️ Leader

🏛️ Position

⚠️ Case Type

⏳ Custody Status

Arvind Kejriwal

    Delhi CM

    Liquor policy (ED case)

Released after 6 months

V. Senthil Balaji

    TN Minister

    Money laundering

Previously jailed

Hemant Soren

    Former Jharkhand CM

    Land scam investigation

Under scrutiny

These cases are illustrative, not exhaustive. The law is not yet enacted, and will undergo scrutiny by a Joint Parliamentary Committee.

🧠 What’s at Stake?

  • Federalism: States could lose autonomy if central agencies can indirectly unseat elected leaders.
  • Presumption of Innocence: A cornerstone of justice, now at risk.
  • Political Fairness: Could this become a tool for vendetta rather than accountability?

🪞A Mirror to Ourselves

This isn’t just about law—it’s about trust. Do we trust our institutions to act fairly? Do we trust our citizens to judge leaders at the ballot box? Or are we shifting toward a system where suspicion is enough to sever a mandate?

Democracy is messy. It’s slow. It demands patience and proof. But that’s what makes it resilient.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

🏠 The Conspiracy to Break India’s Joint Family System

  When Families Break, Markets Flourish In the name of modernity, we’ve traded warmth for Wi-Fi, wisdom for algorithms, and relationships for subscriptions. But this wasn’t just a cultural drift—it was a calculated shift. 🧭 What Was India’s Greatest Strength? For centuries, India stood resilient. Mughals came. The British ruled. But one thing remained unshaken: The Joint Family System. It was our real social security —no pensions, no loneliness, no mental health epidemics. Grandparents were guides. Cousins were companions. Festivals were shared, not streamed. 🧠 Why Did the West Dislike This? Western economies thrive on individualism and consumption . But in India, where people shared, reused, and lived collectively, the market couldn’t grow. So a strategy was born: “Break their families. Make everyone lonely. Then everyone becomes a customer.” 📺 How Was This Attack Carried Out? Media portrayed joint families as quarrelsome and outdated Nuclear families we...
Post a Comment
Read more

🌾 The Boy Who Slept Through the Storm: A Lesson in Preparedness

Once upon a time, near the coastal edge of a village, there lived a farmer whose life depended entirely on his field. The land was fertile, but the skies were unpredictable. Floods and hurricanes visited often, and each time, they brought fear, damage, and sleepless nights. The farmer knew he couldn’t manage alone. He needed help—not just to sow and reap, but to protect what he had built when the winds turned wild. 🧑‍🌾 The Search for a Helping Hand He interviewed many—strong men, clever boys, experienced workers. None felt right. Then one day, a lean, sorrowful-looking boy came asking for work. The farmer hesitated. Could this boy handle the storms? But with no better option, he agreed. The boy accepted—with one strange condition: “When the storm comes, I sleep deeply. Other times, I’ll work as needed.” 🌩️ The Night of the Storm Weeks passed. One night, the skies roared. Rain lashed the earth. Floodwaters rose. The farmer woke in panic and rushed to the boy’s hu...
Post a Comment
Read more

☔ Rain, Ride, and the Biometric Machine:

Some people believe the weather is random. I believe it has a wicked sense of timing—especially during office hours. 🌧️   Morning Madness: The Ride to Remember It all begins with a drizzle. I gear up, hop on my bike, and head toward the office like a determined warrior. But the moment I hit the main road— boom —the skies open up like someone hit the “monsoon mode” switch. Puddles splash, my raincoat flaps like a superhero cape, and visibility drops to “guess and go.” By the time I reach the office, I’m soaked, squelching with every step. I walk in like a waterlogged legend and stood in front of the biometric scanner.   And just like that... the rain stops. Coincidence? I think not. 🕒 The Great Biometric Rain Switch It’s almost as if the rain was waiting for me to clock in. I imagine a weather god somewhere chuckling, “Alright, he’s in. Turn it off.” The day goes on. Files, meetings, coffee. The sun peeks out. Birds chirp. I start to believe the worst is over. But th...
Post a Comment
Read more